Ex-Supreme Court Judge found guilty of misconduct by Supreme Judicial Council

By Naveed Siddiqui
ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) has concluded that retired Supreme Court judge Syed Mazahar Ali Akbar Naqvi was “guilty of misconduct” and recommended his removal from office. The SJC’s decision, headed by Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Isa, comes after a series of complaints and proceedings against Naqvi, who had already resigned in January amidst public scrutiny.
The SJC, comprising prominent legal figures including CJP Isa and Lahore High Court Chief Justice Muhammad Ameer Bhatti, deliberated on the allegations against Naqvi, which emerged after his name was linked to an alleged audio leak. Despite Naqvi’s initial objections and challenges to the proceedings, the SJC continued its investigation.
Naqvi, in response to the allegations, maintained his innocence, asserting that the complaints against him were baseless. However, the SJC proceeded with its inquiry, ultimately finding him guilty of misconduct. Naqvi’s resignation prior to the SJC’s recommendation renders the outcome largely symbolic, as it holds no practical consequence.
In light of this case, the SJC also amended its Code of Conduct to allow judges to respond to publicized allegations without violating ethical guidelines. This decision aims to address concerns raised by judges regarding their ability to defend themselves against public accusations.
Additionally, the SJC’s notice to a Balochistan High Court judge underscores ongoing efforts to maintain judicial integrity and address complaints within the legal community.
The SJC’s ruling on Justice Naqvi’s misconduct underscores the importance of upholding ethical standards within the judiciary. Despite Naqvi’s resignation, the case highlights the SJC’s role in investigating allegations of judicial misconduct and its commitment to transparency and accountability within the legal system